Author: Abhimanyu Kumar
ALG Partner Abhimanyu Kumar reports in the INTA Bulletin, the Bombay High Court’s order in Sanjay Soya Private Limited v. Narayani Trading Company [I.A. No. 5011 OF 2020 in Commercial IP Suit No. 02/2021]. The court vide its order dated March 9, 2021, while injuncting the defendant from using the plaintiff’s registered mark SOYA DROP and copyrighted work, held that unlike in trademarks, copyright registration is not mandatory to claim reliefs under the Copyright Act, 1957.
The INTA Bulletin titled “INDIA: Ability to Sue for Infringement—Trademark vs. Copyright” can be accessed – here.
Disclaimer: Views, opinions, interpretations are solely those of the author, not of the firm (ALG India Law Offices LLP) nor reflective thereof. Author submissions are not checked for plagiarism or any other aspect before being posted.
Copyright: ALG India Law Offices LLP
The contents of this website are meant solely for the purposes of information and updates, and not for the purposes of advertising or soliciting. ALG India Law Offices LLP is not responsible for decision(s) taken by anyone on the basis of information/updates provided in the website.
By clicking "ENTER" below, you acknowledge that the information/ updates provided on the website does not amount to advertising or solicitation.
This website is not a solicitation or invitation to create an attorney-client relationship. No such relationship is created or deemed to be created by visiting this website or by contacting us. This is a passive website intended principally to disseminate published materials already available in the public domain.
We, as well our attorneys, do not take out or subscribe to paid rankings, paid listings, paid endorsements or paid advertisements.
No information is collected nor, if available, from visitors to the site or recipients of the communication, used or permitted to be used for marketing, solicitation or recruiting purposes, nor such information is provided or sold to third parties. No information is collected from you or your browser for any purpose including tracking the popularity of this site and the usefulness of particular links or features. No such information is collected or used to target individuals or to contact them. No “cookies” – files written to your computer and designed to help track website visitors’ surfing activities – are used.
We observe all applicable Bar Council rules and norms in conflict of interest matters. Between practice areas, we do not perceive automatic or deemed conflict of interest. We do not perceive automatic or deemed conflict of interest with closed files unless there is a subject matter overlap. We check for the conflict of interest specifically on a file as against our other existing and live files, and not on a client as against existing client basis, viz. the conflict of interest is strictly on the subject matter against subject matter basis. In case of potential or possibility of being conflicted in the future, however, we seek and take consent from the existing client if we want to take up a file. Our conflict of interest norms are stricter than the minimum standards of the Bar.
We disclose names/identities of our existing clients (but not of their files, nor of the contents of their files nor of any information about them that is or can be expected to be confidential for business/legal purposes) when other clients or potential clients seek us to disclose representative client names/lists etc. If any potential or existing client informs us to except them from this practice, we oblige and refrain from doing so in their regard.
We retain hard copies of materials of a file for a period of 3 months after a file is closed and after that it is destroyed. File intimation is always specifically communicated to the client. We retain any soft copies of materials in a file for a period of 6 months after a file is closed and after that it is deleted. If hard copies are sought to be returned on closure of file, it should be specifically asked for.
The private/personal activities of individual lawyers of the firm (such as, but not limited to, writing and publishing in journals and publications, blogs, and expressing views in the public domain, in print and online media, taking membership of organizations and groups in a private capacity, political activities, membership of political parties, contesting elections and other electoral activities, etc.) are not reflective of the firm, nor does the firm support, endorse or identify with any of them.
ALG attorneys practice only in teams viz. accept appointment as advocates-cum-agents on any file/mandate only jointly in practice-groups of at least two ALG attorneys. At ALG, Advocates and IP Agents also participate and share in and contribute towards discharging certain ancillary and support functions in addition to their primary professional responsibilities as lawyers and IP Agents, and this also they do as part of teams and not as individuals. Management functions such as client-relations generally, as well as on any specific file, previous client relations, potential client relations, billing, expenditure, accounts, infrastructure and office management etc. are all thus discharged by such teams. ALG attorneys are not permitted to engage in any sole or individual practice, not even in an outside-ALG or private capacity.
There is functional specialization in ALG in addition to specializations in Areas of Focus and Areas of Practice. In her/his professional work as an Advocates and/or an IP Agent, each individual at ALG specializes, as part of a team, in certain allocated core functions on any client file and discharges only that core function on any client file, instead of handling a client file in all respects or/and from file opening to file closing.
We assume no liability for any reliance on our communications unless signed in ink and issued as a final written legal opinion. Interim opinions, discussion drafts, email communications, telephone conversations, electronic documents, unsigned communications and memos are not intended to be relied upon either by the addressee or by any third party. No communication nor even an ink signed final written legal opinion is intended unless expressly stated to be so to be cited, filed or tendered before any government or statutory agency or authority. We do not hold out as to the accuracy or validity of any communication or legal opinion to any third parties or at any future time.
Contents of this website and communications are posted for discussion purposes only. It is not intended to be and should not the relied upon as a legal opinion. It may not be relied upon by any person as advice or information, nor is it to be quoted, extracted, excerpted, collated, annexed or referred to in any private, public or official or formal document, nor shown to or filed with any government authority, official, forum or agency or any public body. All references and elucidations of the law or of the statutory or regulatory framework are subjective and interpretative and not intended to be either a full statement or elaboration thereof or as having been verified for authenticity. The material is such as may change with time and the authors do not make any representation as to the validity of the contents of this document. The information on these pages/ communication or on this site do not convey legal advice of any kind. Any use of this communication or site does not create a lawyer-client relationship nor will any information submitted via this site or by email be considered a lawyer-client communication or otherwise be mandated as confidential in the absence of a pre-existing express written agreement to the contrary.
The information contained on this website, in any e-mail and any attachments is legally privileged and confidential. If you are not an intended recipient/visitor, you are hereby notified that any dissemination, distribution or copying is strictly prohibited. If you are visiting by mistake or have received this e-mail in error, please leave/ notify the sender and permanently delete the e-mail and any attachments immediately and you should not retain, copy or use any contents or this e-mail or any attachment or any material at this site for any purpose, nor disclose all or any part of the contents to any other person. This is a privileged client only website and a passive communication for restricted distribution at the sole discretion of its authors who hereby predicate its confidentiality, copyright and circulation to be in the mode and manner described below. This page and other pages/communication, including the contents in attachments or at the site, is intended only for clients or persons who have expressed an interest in receiving it or been expressly referred for this purpose. It is not intended for general or public access or circulation.
Unless otherwise noted, all content and materials, including, but not limited to, articles, reports, images, illustrations, designs, icons, photographs, video clips and audio clips that are part of this communication, including attachments, or at the site (collectively, the “Content”) are protected by copyright vesting in the provider of the Content. You shall abide by all additional copyright notices, information or restrictions contained in any Content accessed through any other means. No Content may be copied, reproduced, framed, hyperlinked, republished, downloaded, uploaded, posted, transmitted, or distributed in any way; provided, however, you may download and/or print, one copy of the Content on any single computer/printer for your personal, non-commercial use only, provided you keep intact all copyright and other proprietary notices. Copying, storing or printing of any Content for other than personal use is expressly prohibited without prior permission. Please contact us in case of any doubt. Use of any robot, spider, other automatic device, or manual process to monitor or copy all or any part of Content is strictly forbidden. Modification of the Content or use of the Content for any other purpose is a violation of copyright and other proprietary rights. For purposes of these terms, the use of any Content in any other communication or site or networked computer environment is prohibited. All trademarks, service marks and trade names are proprietary.
ALG does not adopt, have or implement any differential billing rate, treatment or fee schedule for and amongst its clients, whether domestic or foreign, or between any such or other categories, either on a on a case by case basis or on any such categorization basis. ALG does, however, provide differently customized client-tailored suite of its IP legal representational services for each of its clients resulting in naturally different costs to different clients for what might otherwise superficially appear similar engagements but would be only apparently similar engagements. ALG works closely with each of its clients to understand that client’s needs and requirements to adapt its billing structure, format and arrangement itself for a more conducive mutual fit. ALG does provide special discounts to its clients but this is on the basis of long-standing relationships reflecting sustained and deep engagement and commitment. It provides these automatically and only in accordance with its internal policies, not on request, demand, discretion or ad-hocism. ALG also provides but only in accordance with its internal policy in force at any given time, what are in the nature of bulk discounts for several simultaneous similar or related instructions or engagements. Actually, these reflect value based reductions given the nature of the instructions and engagements as a package. ALG’s billing arrangements for any engagement are predicted on an attorney-client relationship. ALG is a lawfirm and it provides only legal IP representational services; it does not provide non-legal IP business services or non-legal IP liaison services. ALG’s billing is for this reason incapable of being disaggregated in any part into either of these two types of services that ALG does not provide. ALG does not have any generally applicable fee schedules for any generic or pre-defined activities, services, tasks or engagements because ALG does not provide such modular or otherwise template based services.
We at ALG take seriously our commitment to serving and uplifting our communities. To these ends, we strive to fulfil our professional and ethical responsibilities by providing free legal services appropriately to indigent or otherwise needy individuals and organisations; briefs and cases.
The firm expects each ALG lawyer, regardless of designation, to devote a portion of her/his time and energies to providing pro bono legal services (for free or at reduced charge). The firm strongly encourages all ALG lawyers to seek and maintain active empanelment with local and regional Legal Aid Committees, to seek and take up legal cases and matters both in court and outside court, at appropriately discounted if not altogether waived professional fees. All ALG lawyers are strongly encouraged to discharge their duty to the bar, profession and society by doing so and they are not restricted to only intellectual property law cases and matters in this regard.
Each ALG lawyer’s record of pro bono legal work is considered an important factor in that lawyer’s evaluation and taken into consideration for advancement decisions at the firm.
ALG provides the same quality of professional representation and legal service, regardless of an accepted client’s ability to pay. Pro bono matters of ALG lawyers are treated as that of the firm and no differently than regular billable matters, being accorded the same attention, dedication and resources.